AI And Jobs: The Paradox Behind Automation
AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

🔍 Read the full analysis: AI And Jobs: The Paradox Behind Automation on ThorstenMeyerAI.com

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime

  • Fast, free delivery on millions of items
  • Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
  • Member-only deals all year
Start your free Prime trial Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

TL;DR

ATMs automated cash-handling tasks, but US teller employment rose modestly between 1980 and 2010 as banks expanded their branch networks. Mobile banking later became a more direct force reshaping teller work, while US and German branch and employment figures show a longer decline. The account draws on research by economist James Bessen and published government and industry data.

An account published November 20 by ThorstenMeyerAI.com says ATMs reduced the number of tellers needed at each US bank branch, but did not bring an immediate fall in total teller employment: the number of branches grew as automation made them cheaper to operate. The historical case, drawing on economist James Bessen’s research, offers a more qualified view of what happens when machines take over tasks now being discussed in relation to AI.

The first Barclays cash machine opened outside a branch in Enfield, north London, on June 27, 1967. Actor Reg Varney demonstrated it by withdrawing up to £10 in one-pound notes. The earliest machines did not use plastic cards: Barclays’ system used a special paper cheque marked with carbon-14 and a personal code. A German machine opened in Tübingen in May 1968, followed by a Docutel dispenser at a Chemical Bank branch in New York in 1969, according to the article’s cited historical sources.

The machine’s name, automated teller machine, reflected the work it was designed to do: dispense cash and accept deposits. US ATM numbers rose from about 100,000 in 1995 to about 400,000 in 2010, a roughly fourfold increase, according to figures from the Bank for International Settlements used by Bessen. Yet US teller employment rose modestly, from about 500,000 in 1980 to about 550,000 in 2010, according to Bessen’s figures as summarized by MIT economist David Autor.

The account describes opposing changes behind those figures. From 1988 to 2004, a typical urban branch needed about 13 tellers rather than 20, while the number of branches in US cities grew by 43%. The article says automation lowered branch operating costs and that deregulation also made it easier for banks to open branches. It cites Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation counts showing US commercial bank offices rose from 58,937 in 1988 to 77,302 in 2004, then peaked at 88,522 in 2012. Those figures include head offices as well as branches.

At a glance
reportWhen: Published November 20, 2026; covers dev…
The developmentA November 20, 2026, article revisits evidence that ATMs reduced teller needs at each branch without immediately eliminating teller jobs, as cheaper branches and expanding networks offset some of the reduction.
Thorsten Meyer AI
Work After Work · Ep. 18

Infographic 01 · The paradox

Four times the machines, more tellers

ATMs took over the teller's core task. For three decades, banks answered with more branches, not fewer tellers.

×4ATMs in the US, about 100,000 (1995) to 400,000 (2010)
≈ +10%US bank tellers, about 500,000 (1980) to 550,000 (2010)
20 → 13tellers per branch in a typical US city, 1988 to 2004
+43%bank branches in US cities, 1988 to 2004

US commercial bank offices (head offices + branches) · year-end · FDIC

  • 198052,879
  • 198858,937
  • 1995ATMs start to spread fast65,578
  • 200477,302
  • 2012peak88,522
  • 202572,658

Teller and ATM figures: Bessen’s analysis of Census and American Community Survey microdata, as summarised by Autor (2015); ATM counts from the Bank for International Settlements. Branch growth in cities: Bessen (2015), urban markets. FDIC series: FDIC-insured commercial banks in the US states and DC; savings institutions are not included.

Sources: D. Autor, Journal of Economic Perspectives 29(3), 2015; J. Bessen, Toil and Technology, IMF Finance & Development (March 2015); FDIC, Historical Bank Data (commercial banks, year-end).
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI

How Automation Reshaped Teller Work

The case matters because it distinguishes automating tasks from eliminating jobs. An ATM took over some routine cash transactions, but a bank teller’s role included more than dispensing money. As cash handling became less central, banks could place greater emphasis on customer interaction and sales, including advice about loans, credit cards and investments.

That does not mean automation protected every teller position indefinitely. The article’s later figures show a marked change as customers adopted digital banking: in 2023, 48.3% of US households with a bank account mainly used mobile banking, while 15.1% mainly used a teller. US teller employment fell from about 600,500 in 2008 to 339,200 in 2025, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics figures cited in the account. The different periods and measures should not be collapsed into a single cause-and-effect estimate, but they show that employment outcomes can change as technology and customer behavior evolve.

For readers following AI’s effects on work, the lesson is not that new technology necessarily creates jobs or necessarily destroys them. A technology can reduce staffing for particular tasks, change the skills employers seek and alter the cost of providing a service. Whether total employment rises or falls depends on factors including demand, business expansion and the work that remains.

Products Worth Considering

Bose QuietComfort Wireless Bluetooth Noise-Cancelling Headphones, Cypress Green

Bose QuietComfort Wireless Bluetooth Noise-Cancelling Headphones, Cypress Green

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

From Cash Machines to Mobile Banking

The account places the ATM within a longer shift in banking. Initially, cash machines extended access beyond branch opening hours, when customers otherwise had to visit a bank to obtain cash. Later, banks installed them at scale. The article links the period of ATM expansion to a broader increase in branches, which helped offset the need for fewer tellers at each location.

That first phase is distinct from the more recent move to online and mobile banking. The source reports that German bank branches fell from 45,467 at the end of 2004 to 16,799 at the end of 2025, and says cash machines are also retreating in Germany, China and Japan. It does not provide comparable employment figures for those countries or detailed data on ATM closures. The available evidence therefore points to a shift in how banking is delivered, rather than establishing one uniform pattern across countries.

The article uses the term “relationship banking” for work that remained after routine cash transactions moved to machines: interacting with customers and offering financial products. It also cites Autor’s warning that a teller who can count cash but cannot perform customer-facing work may be poorly suited to a modern bank. That is an interpretation of changing job requirements, not a guarantee that workers can move into those roles without training or that banks will retain the same number of employees.

““actually rose modestly from 500,000 to approximately 550,000 over the 30-year period from 1980 to 2010””

— David Autor, MIT economist, summarizing James Bessen’s findings in 2015

What the Employment Figures Cannot Show

The figures do not prove that ATMs alone caused the rise or subsequent decline in teller employment. Branch deregulation, consumer demand, the expansion of banking services and later adoption of mobile banking also affected the industry. The article describes those influences but does not estimate how much each contributed.

The employment counts also cover different time spans and methods. The 1980 and 2010 totals summarized by Autor are not directly interchangeable with Bessen’s full-time-equivalent measure, which divides total teller work hours by 2,080 hours a year. The source says that measure grew by 2.0% annually from 2000 to 2013, faster than the overall labor force, but does not provide enough detail in this account to reconcile it with every other series.

It remains unclear how much of the later fall in teller employment reflects mobile banking, branch closures, other cost-cutting or changes in the way banks classify and organize work. Nor does the historical example establish what AI will do across occupations: its effects will depend on which tasks systems can perform, how businesses respond and whether demand for the services expands.

Tracking Banking’s Next Shift

The article is a historical report, not an announcement of a new banking policy or a forecast with a stated release date. The next useful indicators are updated Bureau of Labor Statistics employment counts, bank branch and cash-machine totals, and data on how customers use mobile, online and in-person services. Comparing those measures over the same periods would help clarify whether reduced teller staffing tracks branch closures, changing service demand or other factors.

For assessing AI and jobs, the same questions apply: which tasks are being automated, what new or remaining work employers require, and whether lower costs expand demand enough to offset staffing reductions. The teller history offers evidence that the first visible effect of a machine may be a changed job rather than the disappearance of an occupation—but it does not predict the outcome for any particular job or industry.

Key Questions

Did ATMs immediately eliminate bank teller jobs?

No. The figures cited by the article show US teller employment rising modestly, from about 500,000 in 1980 to about 550,000 in 2010, even as ATM numbers roughly quadrupled from 1995 to 2010.

Why did teller employment hold up while branches needed fewer tellers?

The article says banks needed fewer tellers at each branch, but US city branches grew by 43% from 1988 to 2004. Lower operating costs from automation and changes to branch-opening rules contributed to that expansion.

What happened to teller jobs after 2008?

The source cites Bureau of Labor Statistics figures showing US teller employment fell from about 600,500 in 2008 to 339,200 in 2025. It points to the rise of mobile banking but does not establish how much of the decline it caused.

Does the ATM example predict what AI will do to jobs?

No. It shows that automating tasks does not automatically determine total employment. The outcome also depends on demand, business expansion and changes to the remaining work; the banking example cannot establish what will happen in other occupations.

Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com

You May Also Like

AI, Productivity, And The Workweek That Wouldn’t Shrink

A November 18 report compares Keynes’s 1930 hopes for shorter hours with a workweek still near 40 hours and early AI time-saving estimates.

What Can Visitors Learn From Exhibit-Based Games?

A proposal would test browser-based museum quests at three small museums, measuring visits and bookings before judging whether the model works.

Why the nation’s founding document is barely legible

The nation’s founding document is becoming increasingly difficult to read due to deterioration and limited preservation efforts, raising concerns about historical preservation.

Akira Ikezoe’s Frogs and Bears Have Something Urgent to Tell Us

Artist Akira Ikezoe’s latest works depict animals in industrial and nuclear settings, highlighting environmental crises and urgent ecological messages.